Write a rubric for judging output

Write a rubric for judging outputs of this task: {{task}}

Here is one I consider good:
{{goodExample}}

Derive the criteria from what makes that one good, not from generic quality words.
Each criterion needs a concrete failing example, or it cannot be applied
consistently. Three to five criteria, weighted.

Then say which criterion my good example only barely passes.

What to fill in

{{task}}

The task being judged — e.g. rewriting support replies in our tone

{{goodExample}}

One output you consider good — e.g. Paste it